Discussion on the Amendment of Numeric Values in Claims

When amending the scope of a claim by narrowing the range of the numeric values, such as narrowing the range of “0.001~2wt%” to “0.1~1wt%” in a claim, intuitively the scope of the claim is narrowed and such amendment seems to be acceptable. However, a simple amendment by narrowing the range of the numeric values in […]

When amending the scope of a claim by narrowing the range of the numeric values, such as narrowing the range of “0.001~2wt%” to “0.1~1wt%” in a claim, intuitively the scope of the claim is narrowed and such amendment seems to be acceptable. However, a simple amendment by narrowing the range of the numeric values in a claim may be deemed to have extended beyond the scope of the original specification and cannot be supported by the original specification therefore.

According to Article 22.II of the Patent Act in Taiwan “Except for correction of translation errors, any amendment shall not extend beyond the scope of content disclosed in the description, claim(s), or drawing(s) as filed.” Furthermore, “Substantive Examination Guidelines for Invention Patent” in Taiwan gives some examples to illustrate the rules of amending the range of the numeric values in claims.

One of the examples in “Substantive Examination Guidelines for Invention Patent” describes that the range of condition for the chemical reaction is pH=6~12 as mentioned in the claim and the embodiment in the specification mentions that the range of preferable condition for the chemical reaction is pH=6~8. If the technical feature pH=10~12” has been disclosed by the prior art, it is allowable to amend the condition in the claim from “pH=6~12” to “pH=6~8” since the specification has disclosed the condition pH=6~8. However, it is not allowed to amend the condition in the claim from “pH=6~12” to “pH=6~9” since the specification does not describe “the range of condition for the chemical reaction is pH=6~9” clearly.

The critical point is whether the numeric value is disclosed and substantively supported by the specification or not. From the previous example, the specification does not disclose the technical feature and the effect that “the condition for the chemical reaction is pH=9”. In general, if an invention needs to be defined by numeric values in order to be distinguished from the prior arts, the said invention usually belongs to the technical fields which are more unpredictable. On the other hand, if the range of an invention is predictable, merely changing the range would be deemed to lack an inventive step. Hence, if a claim of an invention is defined by a range of numeric values, the content of the specification thereof should at least illustrate the connection between the numeric values with upper and lower limits and the special effects which the invention achieves.

A claim should be substantively supported by the specification, which means the specification should describe the claimed technical features and the effects to be achieved. On the contrary, if the specification merely describes various numeric values but does not mention the features and the effects thereof, it would merely be “formally” instead of “substantively” supported by the specification. Although whether a claim is substantively supported by the specification or not depends on the examiner’s point of view in a certain extent, a claim which is “formally” supported by the specification is not consequentially allowable under the practice in Taiwan according to our experience.

Conclusion
The scope of the amended claim is beyond the scope of the specification, claims or drawings.

Explanation
The specification, claims or drawings do not describe the value of 0.1wt % or 1wt %. Furthermore, the range is not specified to “0.1~1wt %”. Hence, the amended range “0.1~1wt %” cannot be directly and unambiguously derived from what is disclosed in the specification, claims or drawings as filed. The said amendment will cause new matters.

Delivered by: Sandy WANG (Ms.) / Senior Partner
Logo_JAW-HWA1JAW-HWA INTERNATIONAL PATENT &
TRADEMARK & LAW OFFICES
10-1A Fl., No. 23, Sec. 1, Chang-An E. Rd.,
Taipei, Taiwan, R.O.C.
Tel.: +886 2 2531-0876 Ext. 172
Fax: +886 2 2581-2761
www.jaw-hwa.com.tw
jawhwa@nulljaw-hwa.com.tw

    • November 2019
      Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun
      « Oct    
       123
      45678910
      11121314151617
      18192021222324
      252627282930  
  • IP4all Weekly Bulletin

    You can subscribe to the weekly IP4ALL Bulletin.

  • Recommended videoView all | 

    The new EU trade mark Regulation enters into force on March 23rd. As a result, the Office for Harmonization in the Internal Market (OHIM) will change its name to the European Intellectual Property Office (EUIPO).

    The amending Regulation also revises the fees payable to the Office, including an overall reduction in their amounts, particularly in the case of trade mark renewal fees. On 23.3. 2016, the Office’s online application forms and fee calculator will be automatically updated to reflect the new system.
    From its base in Alicante, Spain, OHIM has processed more than 1.3 million Community trade mark applications in 23 EU languages, from nearly every country and region in the world, since 1996.

    The Amending Regulation was published on 24 December 2015 and is part of the EU trade mark reform legislative package that also includes the replacement of the existing EU Trade Mark Directive (Directive 2008/95/EC of the European Parliament and the Council).

    OHIM is the EU’s largest decentralised agency. It is entirely self-financed, receiving no funding from the EU Budget. As well as managing the Community trade mark and the registered Community design (RCD), it works in collaboration with the EU national and regional IP offices to build a stronger IP system across the EU for the benefit of users.

  • IP Consulting Ltd. - Intellectual Property Consulting Agency
  • Landmark-TP
  • Ivan Georgiev - Rembrand
  • Global IP Attorneys - The world's leading address guide for patent,  trademark, copyright, intellectual property and IP attorneys. In just a few steps you can find your agency for registration and protection of your intellectual property, patent, design, copyright or trademark.
  • The Professional Sector Network is a referral and networking group that caters exclusively to leading firms with a history of excellence in the business, advisory and investment sectors.
  • IP Basis®

  • IP Guide®

  • Become our partners